Though we have not yet RIGOROUSLY defined the semantics of this operation, we've determined that when two nouns stand in the relationship X Y, X is interpreted as the head and Y as the adjectival modifier. What if Y is not a noun, though?
Turkish, for instance, has a special marker that ties locative phrases to NPs. So
resim masa-da-Ø
picture table-LOC-3sg
"the picture is on the table"
But if we want to say "The picture on the table is pretty," we can't just say
*resim masa-da güzel-Ø
picture table-LOC pretty-3sg
...despite the fact that it makes perfect sense in direct translation. Instead, we see the following:
masa-da-ki resim güzel-Ø
table-LOC-ADJ picture pretty-3sg
"the picture on the table is pretty"
For this reason I was nervous about making any unresearched decisions about similar PPs in Koa. The sentence "the man in the house is bad" (and yes, I know I desperately need to expand my lexicon), for instance, in literal translation would run ka mehe ne ka talo i pua. But is
mehe ne ka talo
man LOC=DEF=house
"man in the house"
okay? Usually I asked this question and then pondered whether it ought to be mehe o ne ka talo, with this o showing that the preceding lexeme is about to be modified by something (I believe o is going to figure in my possessives -- maybe I'll explore this next time). I think, though, that I may be able finally to answer this one satisfactorily. Let's compare the following parallel structures:
As a predicate:
ka talo i iso
DEF=house 3P=big
"the house is large"
ka mehe i ne ka talo
DEF=man 3P=LOC=DEF=house
"the man is in the house"
As an instantiated adjectival:
ka iso
DEF=big
"the big one"
ka ne ka talo
DEF=LOC=DEF=house
"the one in the house"
Therefore, directly modifying a noun, and voilà:
ka talo iso
DEF=house big
"the big house"
ka mehe ne ka talo
DEF=man LOC=DEF=house
"the man in the house"
Considering that these phrases are parallel in the top two cases, I don't see why they would need to be differentiated in the final one. One less thing to worry about.
Friday, February 23, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment